Basic characteristics and prospects of economic development in emerging market countries
Core Tip: The group rise of emerging market countries has changed the world economic and political structure. This paper expounds the background and development trend of emerging market countries from the perspective of economic development, and emphasizes that exploring the economic development of emerging market countries should be based on four perspectives: the relationship between the overall global pattern and emerging market countries, the relationship between major developed countries and emerging market countries, the relationship between different countries within emerging market countries, and the relationship between different members within a specific emerging market country. The economic development of contemporary emerging market countries presents the basic characteristics of tightening environment, increasing overall weight, accelerating structural transformation, country growth differentiation, prominent distribution issues and broad cooperation space.
Abstract: The group rise of emerging market countries has changed the world economic and political structure. This paper expounds the background and development trend of emerging market countries from the perspective of economic development, and emphasizes that exploring the economic development of emerging market countries should be based on four perspectives: the relationship between the overall global pattern and emerging market countries, the relationship between major developed countries and emerging market countries, the relationship between different countries within emerging market countries, and the relationship between different members within a specific emerging market country. The economic development of contemporary emerging market countries presents the basic characteristics of tightening environment, increasing overall weight, accelerating structural transformation, country growth differentiation, prominent distribution issues and broad cooperation space. The future economic development of emerging market countries is worth looking forward to, and the influence of China and India in the global economic structure will be further enhanced. To realize this prospect, it is necessary to respond to possible "disturbance items", and at the same time, emerging market countries need to truly implement the concept of win-win cooperation and continuously activate their internal development potential.
Keywords: emerging market countries BRICS cooperation and win-win community of human destiny
【 Chinese Library Classification Number 】 F113 【 Document Identification Code 】 a
On August 22nd, 2023, in his speech at the closing ceremony of the BRICS Business Forum in 2023, the Chairman of the Supreme Leader emphasized that "in today’s era, the rise of emerging market countries and developing countries, represented by BRICS countries, is fundamentally changing the world map", which not only spoke highly of the great achievements that have been made in the development practice of emerging market countries, but also profoundly expounded the great influence that this practice has had on the historical process of mankind. China is an important member of emerging market countries and a developing country with a population of more than 1.4 billion. On the new journey, China is committed to comprehensively promoting the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation with Chinese modernization. This process is a process of steadily improving the country’s comprehensive national strength and promoting the cause of common prosperity for all people. It is also a process of continuously building a community of human destiny and creating a new form of human civilization. From the operational point of view, China’s modernization drive is related to the overall development trend of emerging market countries in the international dimension and to the high-quality development process in the economic field in the domestic dimension. Based on this, from the economic perspective, it is undoubtedly of great practical value to explore the characteristics of the times faced by the economic development of emerging market countries, and then to judge the possible prospects and guarantee conditions of this development, which is instructive for the steady advancement of Chinese modernization and the continuous enhancement of the international influence of emerging market countries.
Four perspectives on understanding the economic development of emerging market countries
Emerging market countries, represented by BRICS countries, are an important concept in the contemporary world. This concept depicts a "one type" country with some similarities. From the perspectives of national population size, development stage and world significance, this type of country has never appeared in the history of human development before, and its influence on the global pattern is extensive and far-reaching. Its formation background, operational logic and objective influence are obviously worth studying. Starting from grasping the inherent laws of economic development in emerging market countries, theoretical research should focus on four groups of relationships, which correspond to four perspectives to understand the economic development of emerging market countries.
The first is the relationship between the overall global pattern and emerging market countries. That is to say, as a "type" country, the development of emerging market countries is not isolated or accidental, and its impact is not limited to these countries. Therefore, it is necessary to understand emerging market countries in a global context in order to grasp the external environmental characteristics they face and their impact on this environment.
The second is the relationship between major developed countries and emerging market countries. The emerging market countries represented by BRICS countries belong to developing countries as a whole, but they belong to the part with large population, rapid development and strong demonstration effect within developing countries. According to the "center-periphery" theory in international economics, developed countries and developing countries are in different positions in the international division of labor and international trade system, and developing countries often provide primary products in the industrial system and obtain smaller benefits in the industrial value chain. The economic development of emerging market countries will inevitably have an impact on this international economic order, and the economic and trade relations between major developed countries and emerging market countries need to be repositioned and considered.
The third is the relationship between different countries within emerging market countries. Emerging market countries are a "group" concept composed of many countries, and BRICS countries have also formed a transnational economic cooperation mechanism. However, the economic development of these countries is not uniform, and their factor endowments, industrial structure, economic policies and development levels are objectively different. This means that it is also extremely important to analyze the inter-state relations within emerging market countries, and its economic development research must follow the principle of "integration and division". It is inaccurate to regard emerging market countries as "completely homogeneous" or "communities" with super close relations.
Fourth, the relationship between different members in specific emerging market countries. Every country in emerging market countries is composed of large-scale social members. It is a common proposition for these countries to fully stimulate the economic vitality of each member and at the same time transform the development achievements into the social well-being of different members. The most fundamental thing here is that all emerging market countries need to find an efficiency-fairness equilibrium point suitable for their own characteristics, so as to make their "rise" in the economic field sustainable. In this regard, the practice of different emerging market countries is not the same, with both valuable experience and profound lessons. In a word, it is important and complicated to explain the economic development of emerging market countries, which needs to deal with multiple relationships and synthesize multiple perspectives to investigate, so as to form a more systematic and accurate judgment on the economic development of emerging market countries.
Basic characteristics of economic development in emerging market countries
Emerging market countries, represented by BRICS countries, showed a trend of "group rise" after the 1980s, which was embodied in the fact that these countries, as developing countries, all experienced a stage of rapid economic growth, although this growth lasted for a long time or a short time. In a nutshell, these characteristics are mainly reflected in:
First, the environment is tightening. The economic development of emerging market countries is in the overall picture of global development, which is inevitably influenced by the world development trend, and the external environment constitutes the primary factor to understand the development characteristics of emerging market countries. Compared with the 1980s and the early 21st century, the international environment faced by emerging market countries has become more complicated. From high-speed growth to relative contraction, from liberalization to trade pressure, it is the basic trend of global economic development. From the perspective of "openness", the environment faced by emerging market countries at this stage is tightening. This is mainly reflected in two aspects: First, since the international financial crisis in 2008, the global economy has entered a stage of slow growth. Compared with before the crisis, the slowdown in economic growth has become a new feature after the international financial crisis. Due to the lack of major industrial cluster innovation in Schumpeter’s sense, it is still difficult for the global economy to return to the high growth stage before the crisis. Second, with the global economic growth slowing down, some countries, especially the major developed countries, tend to rise in protectionism and unilateralism, and beggar-thy-neighbor thinking and zero-sum game initiatives in international economic exchanges have intensified, which makes the world economic development face a certain degree of "anti-globalization" challenges. The slowdown of global economic growth and the intensification of anti-globalization have led to a profound turning point in the global economic structure. Seeking economic development in adapting to this new pattern is an era proposition that emerging market countries need to face and respond to.
Second, the overall component has increased. The key reason why emerging market countries can become a concept is that these countries, as populous countries, have experienced a long or short period of rapid economic growth. In particular, China and India, two large developing countries with a population of over 1 billion, have maintained a sustained and high-speed economic growth trend for a long time. According to the data in the World Bank database, the average annual GDP growth rates of China and India from 1980 to 2022 were 9.10% and 5.91%, respectively, far exceeding the world average of 2.94% in the same period, and the coefficient of variation of GDP growth rates of China and India were 0.3311 and 0.4454, respectively, also far below the world level of 0.5325, which indicated that the economic growth of the two populous countries was characterized by rapidity, stability and sustainability. This situation has led to a continuous increase in the share of emerging market countries in the global economic aggregate. Compared with major developed countries, the economic influence of emerging market countries has been significantly enhanced, and the world economic structure has shown a trend of "rising east and falling west". According to the constant dollar in 2015, the total GDP of the BRICS countries increased from 10.43% to 16.23% in 1990-2007, and this indicator further increased from 17.08% to 25.64% in 2008-2022. In contrast, from 2008 to 2022, the GDP share of the three major developed economies, the United States, the European Union and Japan, decreased from 53.83% to 45.32%. The economic weight of emerging market countries represented by BRICS countries continues to increase.This has provided the main driving force for pushing the world economic structure towards a new balance and the evolution of division of labor between developed and developing countries.
The third is the acceleration of structural transformation. According to the theory of economic development, the growth of economic aggregate is closely related to the transformation of economic structure. Since 1980s, the rapid economic growth in emerging market countries has been accompanied by the acceleration of structural transformation, especially in developing countries with hundreds of millions of people, such as China, India and Brazil, where the rapid development of industrialization and urbanization is the concentrated representative, which makes the relationship between workers and peasants, urban-rural relations and industrial structure change quite differently from other periods in history. According to the data in the World Bank database, from 1980 to 2022, the proportion of agricultural added value to GDP in China decreased by 22.33 percentage points, while that in India decreased by 17.79 percentage points, and the decline degree of this index in the world was 2.67 percentage points in the same period. In 2022, the agricultural added value of the BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) accounted for 6.81%, 3.90%, 16.62%, 7.30% and 2.57% respectively, and they have all become industrialized countries with the main proportion of non-agricultural industry output value. As far as the urban-rural structure is concerned, the proportion of urban population in the total population in China increased by 44.20 percentage points from 1980 to 2022, with an average annual growth rate of over 1 percentage point, Brazil increased by 22.09 percentage points, and the world increased by 17.57 percentage points in the same period. In 2022, the urbanization rates of BRICS countries were 87.56%, 75.13%, 35.87% and 63.52 respectively.The other four countries have all become countries with a dominant urban population. Considering that the industrial structure is related to the supply system and the urban-rural structure is related to the demand system, the economic structure transformation of emerging market countries has a far-reaching impact on the global economy by changing both ends of supply and demand.
The fourth is the growth and differentiation of countries. Emerging market countries are a group concept. Since the 1980s, these countries have experienced a stage of rapid economic growth. However, due to the differences in endowment conditions, institutional arrangements and policy choices, the degree of economic growth in different countries is not the same, and the economic performance of specific countries in different periods is also different, which makes the characteristics of economic differentiation among different countries in emerging market countries begin to appear. From the perspective of horizontal comparison, there are differences in the economic growth and global influence of emerging market countries. From 1980 to 2022, the average annual growth rate of GDP in China and India reached 9.10% and 5.91% respectively, but it was 2.34% and 2.10% in Brazil and South Africa respectively, and even only 0.81% in Russia (1990-2022). This situation leads to differences in the influence of these countries in the global economic structure. From 2000 to 2022, the proportion of China’s GDP in the world increased from 5.73% to 18.19%, while that of India increased from 1.66% to 3.21%, while the proportion of the other three countries changed very little. In terms of per capita GDP, in 2022, China and Russia were US$ 11,560 and US$ 10,079 respectively, Brazil and South Africa were US$ 8,831 and US$ 6,019 respectively, while India was only US$ 2,085. There is an obvious gap in the level of economic development among the five countries. From the perspective of time series comparison, the economic growth rate of specific countries in different periods is also different. Take Brazil as an example.From 2000 to 2011, the average annual GDP growth rate was 3.79%, but it dropped to 0.69% in 2012-2022, and its economy shifted from rapid growth to low speed. In 2012-2022, the growth rate continued to be lower than the world average. As a result, its GDP share in the world dropped from 2.64% to 2.12%, which was in contrast to the rising share of China and India. From the perspective of horizontal comparison and time series comparison, the economic growth differences of emerging market countries all exist, and even there is a trend of differentiation, which is an important characteristic fact in the development performance of contemporary emerging market countries.
Fifth, the issue of distribution is prominent. As large developing countries, emerging market countries are bound to face the great mission of mobilizing and motivating different social members. In this regard, these countries also pay attention to improving the distribution of growth results among different groups in the process of promoting economic growth. It is the basic logic for emerging market countries to pay attention to and highlight the distribution issues by relying on "making a big cake" to provide the foundation for "dividing a good cake" and relying on "dividing a good cake" to provide the impetus for "making a big cake" continuously. Taking $1.9 per day (purchasing power parity in 2022) as the poverty line standard, from 1993 to 2019, the proportion of poor people in China dropped from 62.7% to 0.1%, and that in India dropped from 47.6% to 10.0%, which dropped by 62.6 and 37.6 percentage points respectively, which obviously exceeded the decline of the proportion of poor people in the world of 27.2 percentage points in the same period. China and India are large developing countries with a population of more than 1 billion. Their poverty reduction is rapid and involves a large population. As a result, the distribution of different income groups in China has improved, and it has played a decisive role in the overall poverty reduction performance in the world. Emerging market countries pay attention to transforming economic growth into the improvement of residents’ welfare level, thus solving the imbalance between growth and development to some extent. For example, from 1980 to 2021, the life expectancy of men in China, India and Brazil increased by 13.36 years, 12.21 years and 10.07 years respectively, while that of women increased by 14.44 years, 15.19 years and 11.83 years respectively.Both are higher than the world average of 8.94 years old and 9.24 years old. Obviously, in the sense of human development index, emerging market countries have generally achieved remarkable results, and improving income distribution and residents’ welfare in growth has become an important choice for their economic development.
Sixth, there is a broad space for cooperation. Against the background of great changes in the world in the past century, emerging market countries have similar national conditions (all large developing countries), the same development goals (towards high-income countries or developed countries) and similar international environment (anti-globalization tendency is beginning to rise). Developing and strengthening economic cooperation in emerging market countries is in line with their respective development demands, and "holding a group to keep warm" and "coordinated action" are helpful to enhance their respective economic development momentum. As far as practical basis is concerned, emerging market countries represented by BRICS countries also have broad space for cooperation. These economies are big countries in population and labor force. In 2022, the population of BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) was 215 million, 140 million, 1.417 billion, 1.412 billion and 60 million respectively, accounting for 40.85% of the world. Considering that these countries are moving towards high-income countries, the size of population and labor force means that the five countries can form closer economic and trade exchanges in terms of product demand and factor supply. Due to the differences in factor endowments and development stages, the industrial structure of BRICS countries is different, and their industrial development has its own characteristics. In 2022, the high-tech exports of BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) accounted for 11.35%, 9.13%, 11.03%, 31.28% and 5.62% of the manufactured goods exports, respectively, and China’s advantages are more prominent.In 2019, its industrial labor productivity was US$ 17,700, US$ 23,600, US$ 58,000, US$ 27,400 and US$ 21,900 respectively, and its agricultural labor productivity was US$ 9,992, US$ 14,201, US$ 5,609 and US$ 7,270 respectively. China and Russia have comparative advantages in industrial labor productivity, while Russia and Brazil have comparative advantages in agricultural labor productivity.
The prospect of economic development in emerging market countries
The group rise of emerging market countries is a major event that profoundly affects the world pattern, and the economic development logic of emerging market countries is worth exploring in depth. Based on the unprecedented changes in the world in the past century, the foregoing describes the basic characteristics of its economic development from four perspectives closely related to emerging market countries, namely, the tightening of the environment, the increase of the overall weight, the acceleration of structural transformation, the growth and differentiation of countries, the prominent distribution issues, and the broad space for cooperation. These six characteristics have made a multi-dimensional "portrait" of the economic development of emerging market countries, which means that when expounding the economic development of emerging market countries, It is necessary to introduce the external environment of this type of country, the national differences within this type of country, the structural changes and income distribution corresponding to economic growth, and grasp its development trend from a dynamic perspective. Depicting the current characteristics is to a great extent to serve the future prospect. From the perspective of prospect judgment, the future economic development trend of emerging market countries is worth looking forward to. This is mainly because: India and China are the top two countries in the world in terms of population size. At this stage, these two countries are in the stage of sustainable development of industrialization, urbanization, informationization and agricultural modernization. The resource allocation efficiency and growth potential that may be released by this structural transformation cannot be underestimated. For example, in China, "realizing the full transfer of labor from the primary industry to the secondary industry can effectively improve the efficiency of labor allocation, and then significantly enhance the overall labor productivity". Compared with major developed countries,China and India are still abundant in labor resources, and they still have comparative advantages based on market logic in international division of labor. In recent years, China has actively promoted the transition from "population quantity dividend" to "population quality dividend", and at the same time improved the efficiency of factor combination by deepening economic system reform and strengthening scientific and technological innovation. In addition, with the improvement of per capita GDP level and income distribution gap, China and India will have more prominent market size advantages, and their driving functions on the demand side for industrial transformation and technological change will be enhanced, resulting in new technologies, new industries, new formats and new models that will bring new growth points. Based on their respective factor endowments and comparative advantages, the degree of economic relevance among emerging market countries is likely to increase, and the influence of emerging market countries in important international economic organizations may also increase. Based on the above factors, the fundamentals of economic development in emerging market countries are relatively solid. In particular, China and India, two populous countries, will still maintain rapid economic growth and play a more important supporting and driving role in world economic growth.
While we are optimistic about the economic development of emerging market countries, we should also see that this development involves the international situation and many countries and is the result of the interaction and common promotion of various variables. This means that when judging the future, we should not only see the "fundamentals" and the side that is conducive to economic development, but also see the "disturbance term" and the side that is not conducive to economic development. Based on the above analysis, the economic development of emerging market countries in the future may be affected by the following factors: First, the global economy is in a low growth stage for a long time, and its recovery to high growth is long, and "tightening external market environment" has become the "new normal" that emerging market countries have to face. Second, the geopolitical conflicts on a global scale have not slowed down, the conflict between Russia and Ukraine may become long-term, and geopolitical conflicts in other regions or certain periods may erupt or intensify, which has increased the environmental "uncertainty" of economic development in emerging market countries as a whole. Third, the trend of anti-globalization and trade protectionism continues, even increasing in terms of spatial scope and intensity. In particular, the "trade war", "science and technology war" and "information war" launched by the United States against China may still last for a long time. Fourth, the differences in development trends among emerging market countries have become larger. Coupled with the intervention of international political factors, the degree of differentiation among emerging market countries has intensified, and economic cooperation among their internal countries may fluctuate, and their "coordinated actions" in the field of global economic development may also change. Fifth, emerging market countries still have big shortcomings in innovation investment.The quality of its economic development needs to be further improved, and the contribution of total factor productivity is far from that of major developed countries. In 2018, the R&D expenditure intensities of the BRICS countries-Brazil, Russian Federation, Indian, China and South Africa-were 1.17%, 0.99%, 0.66%, 2.14% and 0.69%, respectively, which were lower than the world average of 2.20%.
Obviously, the future prospect of economic development in emerging market countries is worth looking forward to, and people have reason to be optimistic about it, but this development prospect is not automatic. As a constituent country of emerging market countries, it is necessary for China to take precautions, strengthen the bottom line thinking while pursuing lofty goals, and form a systematic response plan in terms of understanding, strategy and measures for possible shocks. As far as emerging market countries are concerned, a crucial way to respond is that all member countries of emerging market countries should truly implement the development concept of win-win cooperation based on their common development demands. For example, under the concept of building a community of human destiny, China has actively promoted the construction of the Belt and Road since 2013, and actively promoted the establishment of multinational economic organizations such as the BRICS New Development Bank and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank. Emerging market countries can achieve win-win economic cooperation by actively participating in these initiatives and multinational economic organizations, which is also an important measure for emerging market countries to hedge against the slow growth of the global economy and the trend of anti-globalization. For specific countries in emerging market countries, the development conditions and development goals they face are different. Based on this, the key point of promoting economic development is to make full use of their comparative advantages within the country, and rely on institutional innovation and technological innovation to gradually turn comparative advantages into competitive advantages, so as to form a powerful kinetic energy for sustainable economic development through the improvement of domestic economic system and the enhancement of innovation ability. At present, China has embarked on a new journey of building a socialist modern country in an all-round way.And high-quality development is the primary task of building a socialist modern country in an all-round way. In the economic field, high-quality development means effective improvement of economic quality and reasonable growth of economic quantity. Therefore, China must adhere to the principle of "striving for progress while maintaining stability" in economic development, and make use of the coordination of policy combinations, especially fiscal policy, monetary policy and industrial policy, to keep the economic growth rate relatively stable and avoid the rapid "downward step" or violent shock. At the same time, we must make use of the effective market and the government to accelerate the new urbanization and rural comprehensive revitalization, form new development momentum in the interaction of urban and rural factors and the integration of urban and rural development, accelerate the market-oriented reform process of land, labor, capital and other factors, make the "price" more accurately reflect the relative scarcity of factors, and accelerate the construction of a unified national market in the improvement of infrastructure and the unification of rules. Relying on the improvement of science and technology system and mechanism to stimulate the innovation vitality of all kinds of enterprises, strengthen the investment in basic research and the efficiency of innovation transformation, so as to improve the total factor productivity and the quality of economic growth, and promote the transformation of development mode on the basis of responding to external shocks. These measures are crucial to the high-quality economic development of China in the future, and also to the sustained economic growth of emerging market countries and even the global economy in the future.
(The author is a professor and doctoral supervisor at Fudan University School of Economics)
[Note: This paper is a phased achievement of the National Social Science Fund’s major project "Research on the New Urban-Rural Relationship under the Background of Building a Well-off Society in an All-round Way" (project number: 17ZDA066)]
[References]
① Bai Zhongen, Zhang Qiong, Wu Binzhen and Li Yan: China’s Economy Towards 2035: Growth Potential and Industrial Change, Comparison, No.2, 2023.